Idea 1
What drives the G6sulfur Australian rainfall anomaly in UKESM1-0-LL? An ensemble and G6solar diagnosis
What it would do.
- Take UKESM1-0-LL G6sulfur, G6solar, SSP5-8.5 and SSP2-4.5 monthly temperature and precipitation over Australia.
- Recompute the authors' climate classes from their published code, for every available member rather than one.
- Diagnose the Australian rainfall anomaly: its seasonality, the circulation and moisture transport, and lower-stratospheric temperature.
- Contrast G6sulfur with G6solar to see whether the anomaly belongs to the aerosol layer specifically (for example through stratospheric heating) or appears under any uniform dimming. Heating is one candidate, not the default: Visioni et al. (2021) note "Interestingly, the model with the highest AOD in the tropics, UKESM1-0-LL, is also one of the models showing the least amount of stratospheric heating" (p. 10047).
The goal is a UKESM-specific mechanism for a feature the authors report in all models but leave unexplained. What UKESM shows is not assumed.
Why it is new. The authors document the open problem (author documented). The anomaly is not their own diagnostic: they cite it to Fig. 10 of Visioni et al. (2021). Two published results use different baselines:
- Visioni et al. (2021), Fig. 10 (p. 10054), cited by Brunelli & Diamond: "Precipitation changes (mm/day) in the period 2081–2100 in G6sulfur compared to the same period for SSP2-4.5". This is a same-period G6sulfur minus SSP2-4.5 difference. The UKESM1-0-LL panel was read visually only (positive shading over Australia at 300 dpi, Dr. Doubt, 15 Oct), with no number. Visioni's text does not mention Australia.
- Haywood et al. (2023), UKESM1: changes for 2081–2100 relative to a nominal present day, "this is taken as the mean over 2015– 2034 from the ssp245 experiment." (p. 15309). Results are seasonal (JJA and DJF) and "Unless otherwise stated, all results are ensemble means." (p. 15309), from three-member ensembles (p. 15308). For Australia: "In both cases G6sulfur shows changes very similar to ssp245 and ssp585, while G6MCB is significantly different." (p. 15312), next to G6MCB changes where "The simulations presented here show changes over northern Australia in JJA that exceed 500 %." (p. 15312).
These are not in conflict; they measure different things (inferred). Adding the G6solar contrast and a member spread is not something either paper does (inferred). Our search (WebSearch tool, 15 Oct 2026, ~08:15–08:20 BST; queries "G6sulfur Australia precipitation increase mechanism UKESM stratospheric aerosol injection" and "Köppen climate classification stratospheric aerosol injection ARISE-SAI climate zone shifts") found no paper diagnosing this anomaly in UKESM. This is a limit of that search, not a finding.
Feasibility for Ananth. High, and no new simulations are needed (inferred).
- The CEDA records for UKESM1-0-LL G6sulfur and G6solar (checked 15 Oct) both list Amon tables, the variables tas and pr, and members r1i1p1f2, r4i1p1f2 and r8i1p1f2.
- ESGF search (esgf.ceda.ac.uk, Dr. Doubt, 15 Oct ~08:20 BST): MOHC UKESM1-0-LL Amon tas and pr exist for r1i1p1f2, r4i1p1f2 and r8i1p1f2 in G6sulfur, G6solar, ssp245, ssp585 and historical, all held at esgf.ceda.ac.uk. This is a dataset-listing check only; file time coverage (2085–2099), versions and JASMIN access were not checked.
- The authors' own UKESM members are listed in SI Table S1, which could not be read (Wiley returns 403 on open routes; not bypassed). Their data references cite a NIMS-KMA UKESM ssp245 dataset, whose only ESGF member is r13i1p1f2. Their published code (GitHub/Zenodo, commit 96f720a) loads UKESM tas and pr files named r1i1p1f2 for G6sulfur, ssp245, ssp585 and historical in the scatterplot notebooks, but the notebook that builds the class files uses placeholder paths, and the class files on Zenodo carry no member metadata. The members behind the published classes are therefore unconfirmed, and must be matched to SI Table S1 before claiming an exact reproduction.
- The authors' code and processed UKESM class files are open on Zenodo.
- JASMIN/CEDA access is assumed, not verified (inferred).
Evidence base.
- (author documented) Sect. 3.3: "This result likely requires further investigation into the precipitation dynamics of G6sulfur within each model and how SAI implementation affects both regional and global circulation (see Figures S13–S15 in Supporting Information S1 for individual model results)."
- (author documented) Sect. 3.4: "A positive precipitation anomaly occurs over Australia in all models running G6sulfur (see Fig. 10 in Visioni et al., 2021); this regional feature over Oceania merits additional investigation."
- (author documented) Sect. 3.4: "In CNRM-ESM2-1, MPI-ESM1-2-LR, and UKESM1-0-LL, land that is classified as hot arid desert (BWh) historically moderates to a hot semiarid (BSh) classification under G6sulfur; in CESM2-WACCM and IPSL-CM6A-LR, land that is historically hot semiarid transitions to hot arid desert under SSP2-4.5 and SSP5-8.5 but not under G6sulfur."
- (author documented) Sect. 2.1: "This study uses one ensemble member from the six global climate models (GCMs) that participated inthe GeoMIP G6sulfur experiment" (the "inthe" is printed so).
- (inferred) That the G6solar contrast can separate an aerosol-specific part of the anomaly is a design choice; the paper does not use G6solar.
- Related work checked:
- Haywood et al. (2023), ACP 23, 15305–15324, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-23-15305-2023: "In both cases G6sulfur shows changes very similar to ssp245 and ssp585, while G6MCB is significantly different."
- Visioni et al. (2021), ACP 21, 10039–10063, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-21-10039-2021 (cited by the authors for the anomaly, Fig. 10, p. 10054; UKESM heating remark, p. 10047).