Idea 1
Why is UKESM1-0-LL's future aerosol forcing smaller than its historical forcing?
UKESM1-0-LL already has two fixed-SST forcing pairs: the RFMIP pair (1850 vs 2014 aerosol) and the RAMIP pair (SSP3-7.0 vs SSP1-2.6 aerosol in 2050, with 2050 greenhouse gases). The idea is to follow the forcing chain through each pair, globally and region by region: forcing per unit SO2 emission and per unit aerosol optical depth, sulfate formed per unit SO2, and cloud droplet number and size per unit optical depth.
The catch is that the two pairs differ in many ways at once, not just one. They differ in greenhouse-gas year, in how polluted the starting point is, in whether aerosol is added or removed, in the size and location of the change (the authors link the larger future spread partly to "the change in the spatial pattern of aerosol emissions"), in which species change, in the chemistry and oxidant state that sets how much sulfate forms, in natural emissions, and possibly in model version (several of these are our inference). Both pairs use pre-industrial sea surface temperatures, so "warming" here can only mean the land and atmosphere adjusting to 2050 greenhouse gases (inferred). The comparison can describe where UKESM's chain differs between the pairs, but it cannot pin the difference on any one cause or show saturation as the reason. An optional pair of new runs that changes only the greenhouse-gas year (2050 aerosol with 1850 greenhouse gases) would isolate that single factor and nothing more; if it also moved ozone or chemistry, it would isolate a greenhouse-gas-plus-chemistry year. That design is ours.
Similar base-state tests exist for other models. GFDL-ESM4.1 found the global-mean aerosol ERF "relatively robust" while "regional aerosol ERF differs strongly depending on the background climate and composition" (Zhang et al., 2026), and CESM2 showed "statistically insignificant increases in aerosol ERF when estimated in the different background climates" (White et al., 2025). We found no published UKESM1 test of this kind, which reflects our search, not a finding. The diagnostic stage needs no new simulations: the RFMIP pair is on ESGF, and the RAMIP UKESM runs list the cloud, optical-depth and sulfate-production variables on CEDA. Ananth's UKCA/GLOMAP background suits reading these diagnostics; that link is ours (inferred), not the paper's.